Leading an OSINT Team: Unique Challenges

Leading an Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) team presents unique challenges that differentiate it from other forms of team leadership and management. These distinctions warrant exploration and discussion.

This perspective is informed by our leading open source teams within government settings. Based on conversation with other experts the same sorts of challenges exist in the private sector.

---

Challenge 1: Recruitment

Successful OSINT teams require individuals who blend creativity with an intrinsic curiosity, qualities that are often difficult to identify using standard recruitment methods. Traditional approaches may fall short of identifying candidates with the potential to excel in this field.

An effective recruitment method involves tasking candidates with creating an OSINT profile on a topic or person, which they then present during interviews. This allows candidates to demonstrate their research process, analytical thinking, and ability to compile findings into a coherent product.

However, it can be challenging to find suitable topics or people for candidates to research. Ethically, it may be best to have consenting recruitment panel members profiled or suggest research topics which don’t delve into any one individual’s personal life too deeply.

Presenting research provides insights into a candidate’s problem-solving approaches and resilience in the face of a challenge. Experience suggests candidates who admit (often with embarrassment) to diving into research "rabbit holes" are often ideal for OSINT work. After all, the skill to manage scope can be taught, but innate curiosity and passion for open source intelligence are foundational.

Neurodiversity is a significant consideration in OSINT team management, as the nature of OSINT research seems to attract minds that enjoy intense research dives matched with periods of lower-focus. Notice the neurodivergent who apply to work with your organization and don’t be quick to discount what they can bring to the table.

---

Challenge 2: Managing Change

OSINT practices evolve rapidly due to shifts in technology, societal trends, and evolving online communities. Teams must remain adaptable to stay effective. Managers face the dual challenge of fostering innovation while ensuring operational alignment with

broader organizational objectives. That is, the team must still deliver towards the goals of the organisation (which may be relatively consistent year in, year out) while everything they work on changes every 12 months.

Managers should prioritize fostering creativity and exploration within their teams, allocating time for experimentation and innovation. Structured and well-managed learning and tradecraft research activities can encourage engagement and skill development among team members.

Additionally, managers must advocate for the team's needs with senior leadership, emphasizing the importance of technological flexibility, experimental freedom, and time for creative exploration.

These challenges, while significant, are essential to address in order to maintain a team's relevance and productivity. Neglecting them can result in a loss of effectiveness over time.

---

Challenge 3: Understanding Policy and Ethics

OSINT managers often lead teams that operate at the intersection of rapidly evolving policy and ethical considerations. Organizational policies may lag behind operational needs, requiring managers to navigate these gaps effectively.

Understanding national and organizational legal and policy frameworks is critical. This knowledge equips managers to engage stakeholders constructively, addressing concerns and fostering an environment of trust. Rather than obstructing operations, informed managers can build pathways for responsible and effective practices.

In addition, ethical considerations are paramount. OSINT managers must define clear boundaries—what constitutes acceptable practices within "white hat," "grey hat," and "black hat" activities. These limits must be documented, justified, and consistently applied across varying operational contexts.

For smaller organizations, the legal and policy environment may be less rigid, but ethical challenges remain constant. A proactive approach to addressing these issues is essential for maintaining integrity and operational credibility.

---

Challenge 4: Managing Staff Wellness

Staff wellness is a critical consideration for OSINT teams, particularly given the exposure to graphic material that many investigators face. Managers have a significant role in ensuring the necessary support structures are in place.

Organizations must provide accessible wellness resources and actively promote their use among staff. Managers should foster an open culture that encourages discussions about the psychological impacts of the work and personal limits.

Additionally, managers must remain vigilant, monitoring for signs of stress or burnout before they escalate. A proactive approach to workload management and team support ensures long-term team health and effectiveness.

---

Conclusion

Leading an OSINT team involves addressing unique challenges in recruitment, adaptability, policy navigation, and staff wellness. While these challenges are significant, they are manageable with deliberate strategies and a focus on fostering a dynamic and supportive team environment. Wayfinder Intelligence can support your organisation taking this journey, mentoring junior and senior leaders to ensure your OSINT practice is sustainable and effective.